All-on-4 vs All-on-6: what the evidence actually says
Neither, on the evidence published so far. The largest analysis of the two approaches found broadly similar implant survival, bone loss and complication rates, and its own authors say the findings should be read with caution. How many implants your arch needs is decided by your bone, your bite and your planning scan, not by which number sounds safer in a brochure.
What does the published evidence actually compare?
A systematic review and meta-analysis published in the International Journal of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery in 2026 pooled 55 studies drawn from four databases. It covered 19,821 implants in the All-on-4 group and 5,671 in the All-on-6 group, with 453 and 103 failures respectively.
That is the most complete picture available at the moment. It is worth knowing what it is made of before quoting any figure from it.
What do the pooled survival figures show?
Very little daylight between the two. At one year, pooled survival was 99.2 per cent for All-on-4 and 100 per cent for All-on-6. Between one and five years it was 99.7 per cent and 98.6 per cent. Beyond five years it was 98.1 per cent and 97.5 per cent.
The ranking changes depending on which follow-up window you look at. That is itself informative.
Why can those figures not settle the argument?
Because of how the studies were built. Of the 55, five were randomised trials, and the review states that only one of those directly compared All-on-4 with All-on-6. The other four were effectively treated as single-arm studies.
The two groups are also very different in size, roughly 20,000 implants against 5,700, and they are not matched populations. The authors report high heterogeneity between studies and conclude that both techniques showed similar outcomes, while adding that the conclusions should be interpreted with caution because of that heterogeneity.
In plain terms: a page telling you that six implants are measurably better, or that four are, is reading more into these numbers than the numbers carry.
Is there any outcome where the two differ?
One, and it leans towards six. Pooled marginal bone loss, meaning the bone that recedes around the implant neck over time, was close at one year: 0.77 mm for All-on-4 and 0.85 mm for All-on-6. At five years it was 1.28 mm for All-on-4 and 0.94 mm for All-on-6.
Complication rates ran the other way by a hair. Pooled mechanical complications were 5.9 per cent for All-on-4 and 6.6 per cent for All-on-6; biological complications were 6.5 per cent and 7.4 per cent.
No gap there is large, and every one carries the same caution. If you want the detail of what actually breaks in a full arch and how often, we wrote about that separately in All-on-4 problems: what actually goes wrong, and how often.
So what actually decides the number?
Your anatomy, measured rather than estimated. A cone beam scan shows how much bone sits where, and two structures constrain the back of the jaw: the sinus above in the upper jaw and the nerve below in the lower one. Four implants angled forward exist precisely to work within those limits.
Where there is bone to carry six, six is often placed. Where there is not, the honest options are four well-positioned implants, bone grafting, a sinus lift, or, in severe upper-jaw bone loss, zygomatic implants.
One correction worth making: the four-implant approach reduces the need for grafting. It does not abolish it, and any plan that promises otherwise before a scan has been read is promising too early.
If you want to know which number your own jaw can take, a free online assessment with your scan is the shortest way to find out.
Does the bridge on top matter more than the number underneath?
Often it does. The same review reports that mechanical complications may be reduced with zirconia prostheses compared with acrylic ones. That is a materials decision, and on the published evidence it bears at least as much on what breaks as the implant count does.
The trade-off is real in both directions. Zirconia is strong and holds its colour, but a major repair is a bigger job. An acrylic hybrid is easier to repair chairside and easier to replace a tooth on. Neither material belongs to a particular implant number, whatever you may read.
Does six implants mean more safety if one of them fails?
Partly, and not automatically. More fixtures spread the chewing load and leave more support if one is lost. But position outweighs count: six implants in poor bone, poorly distributed, are not better than four placed where the bone is sound.
Implant losses in full-arch work cluster in the early period rather than late, which is why the healing months matter more than the arithmetic. That timing is set out in the post linked above.
Does All-on-6 cost more, and does that money buy anything?
It usually costs more. Two extra implants mean two more components, more surgical time and often more laboratory work; our price list sets out where full-arch treatment sits.
Whether the extra buys you anything depends entirely on your bone. A clinic proposing six is not necessarily selling you something, and a clinic proposing four is not necessarily cutting a corner. The thing that should give you pause is a number quoted before anyone has looked at a scan.
What should you ask before you agree to a number?
How many implants, and why that number for your bone specifically
What the bridge will be made of, and what happens if it chips or fractures
Whether grafting or a sinus lift forms part of the plan, and at which visit
Who places the implants, and in what setting
What the guarantee covers, in writing, before you travel
What is the sensible next step?
Not a quote. A plan. Send photographs and a recent scan or radiograph if you have one, and we will tell you how many implants your arch can carry and why. If the answer is four, we will say four.
Nobody needs to fly abroad for a single filling. Our difference shows in extensive treatment and in cases where risk has to be managed, and deciding how many implants an arch needs is part of managing it. Routine checks and hygiene appointments afterwards are done by a dentist where you live, as they are for anyone with implants.
If you are weighing a fixed bridge against the denture you already wear, that is a different comparison and we have written it out in All-on-4 or dentures?
Start with a free online assessment, or read the All-on-4 and All-on-6 page first if you would rather see the treatment in full before writing to anyone.
Source: Shao, Chen, Wang, Duan, Zhang and Tang, International Journal of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery, 2026.
Last reviewed: November 2026
.png)
Comments