top of page
  • Whatsapp
  • Instagram
  • Facebook
  • Youtube
  • TikTok

Root canal or take it out and put an implant in?

4 days ago
5 min read

Usually the tooth, if enough of it is left. Published comparisons of root canal treatment against extraction and a single implant find high survival on both sides and no consistent winner. What separates the outcomes is not the procedure. It is how much sound tooth still stands, whether the root is intact, and whether a restoration can grip what remains.

That last question is also the weakest part of the published evidence, and we would rather say so than quote a percentage.

Do a root-canalled tooth and an implant last about as long as each other?

Broadly, yes, across the follow-up actually studied. A 2025 systematic review in Acta Odontologica Scandinavica searched six databases and found twelve studies comparing the two directly: seven cohort, four case-control and one randomised. Failure across them ran from 0.7% to 12%, with no significant difference in most.

That range is a spread across twelve dissimilar studies, not a measured difference between the options. The reviewers could not pool them; heterogeneity in design, population and outcome measurement ruled out a meta-analysis. Minimum follow-up was one year, the mean 2.8 years.

Why does how much tooth is left decide this more than the procedure does?

Because root canal treatment deals with the inside of the tooth, and what usually fails afterwards is the outside. A 2025 systematic review in Cureus, covering five clinical studies and 1,165 teeth, concluded that preserving coronal tooth structure is the most decisive factor in the prognosis of a restored root-treated tooth.

So the question is not "root canal or implant", but whether enough sound tooth stands above the gum to hold a restoration for years. What the restoration removes is part of that sum, covered in how much of a tooth a veneer or crown takes.

How much of the tooth has to be left for a root canal to be worth doing?

Those reviewers concluded that teeth which have lost one to three surfaces can be restored with direct composite without significantly compromising survival, while those losing four or five need full coverage.

Two cohorts give a sense of scale. In 401 teeth followed for 60 to 192 months, crowned teeth survived at 94% and composite-restored teeth at 91.9%. In a ten-year cohort of 420 teeth, 91.3% of crowned and 76% of non-crowned teeth were still in place. Two cohorts, not a pooled answer.

What does the evidence say about the ferrule and the remaining walls?

Less than you would expect. The Cureus reviewers defined ferrule height and axial wall categories in advance, then reported that no included study gave fracture outcomes broken down by both restoration type and those categories. Its certainty was graded very low.

So a millimetre threshold for a ferrule comes from laboratory work and convention, not a trial that measured survival against it. That does not make it unimportant; the same reviewers call maintaining a ferrule critical. It means the judgement belongs on your tooth, on a current radiograph, before anything is cut.

Does a crack that runs into the root change the answer?

Yes, and it is one of the clearest points at which removing the tooth becomes the honest recommendation. A fracture running into the root cannot be sealed by treating the canal, because the crack is in the tooth, not the pulp. Where the line runs below bone level, keeping the tooth generally means keeping the problem.

How much root is still held by bone matters for the same reason. We know of no published clinical figure setting a safe threshold there, so we will not invent one.

Can a root canal that has already failed be done again?

Often, yes. Retreatment of a root-filled canal is an established option, and was one of the interventions in the Acta review. Whether it is right depends on why the first attempt failed and what is left afterwards, because each entry takes more structure with it.

Which option needs more attention after the work is finished?

On the published evidence, the implant. Several comparison studies in the Acta review found implants needed more unscheduled visits and further procedures than root-treated teeth, even where survival was similar. Reported pain, satisfaction and quality of life were alike.

That matters more when travelling, so the plan should be written down before you fly. We have set out separately what tends to break, and whether the broken part can be replaced. Routine checks and hygiene afterwards are carried out by a dentist where you live.

If you are weighing this up, send photographs and a current radiograph for a free online assessment and get an opinion on whether the tooth looks restorable before booking.

When is taking the tooth out genuinely the better decision?

When too little sound tooth remains to hold a restoration, when a fracture runs into the root, or when a tooth has been treated and retreated and still causes trouble. Then removing it and planning an implant is not giving up on the tooth; the tooth has gone. The site afterwards is its own question, covered in not having enough bone.

Nobody needs to fly abroad for a single filling. Our difference shows in extensive treatment and in cases where risk has to be managed, and a tooth whose root, walls and neighbours must all be weighed before anything is removed is exactly that case.

How good is the evidence behind all of this?

Weaker than a single confident percentage would suggest. The Cureus review graded its certainty low for the survival comparison and very low for how remaining tooth structure changes the result; four of its five studies were observational. The Acta review is sharper: its single randomised trial planned 240 patients, 120 per arm, analysed 20, and was judged at high risk of bias.

One more, because it cuts against a figure we could have used. The Cureus review puts the long-term advantage of crowning at roughly 13 to 19 percentage points, yet one of its own cohorts shows about two. A figure that does not match the study behind it should not be repeated, so we left it out.

What should you ask before you agree to either?

  • How many sound walls are left, and can a ferrule be made?

  • Is the root intact on the radiograph, and how much is still held by bone?

  • Has this tooth been root-treated before, and if so, why again?

  • If it is kept, what restoration is planned, and how much more tooth will that take?

  • If it is removed, when would an implant go in, and what happens meanwhile?

A clinic that answers those five in writing is making a clinical decision. One that answers only with a survival percentage is making a sales one.

Root canal treatment and implant treatment are planned at Casas Clinics from photographs and a current radiograph. Costs are on our prices page, cover for complications in our guarantee policy. Send yours for a free online assessment and we will tell you what we see. If the honest answer is to keep the tooth and treat it where you live, we will say so.

Sources: Borda MF and colleagues, Acta Odontologica Scandinavica, 2025. Al-Meshal SK and colleagues, Cureus, 2025.

Last reviewed: November 2026

Recent Posts

See All

Comments


Commenting on this post isn't available anymore. Contact the site owner for more info.
bottom of page